POLL: Which Timeless Tale of Time Travel is STAR TREK Fans' Most Treasured?

DECEMBER 13, 2023 - Time travel has been a recurrent theme in the vast universe of Star Trek, captivating audiences across generations with its intricate narratives and paradoxical twists. Spanning multiple series and timelines, Star Trek's exploration of temporal anomalies has left an indelible mark on science fiction storytelling. 

I put a poll out on our Twitter/X account on the 12th of November (apologies for the delay in writing about it) and asked which ones people liked.

Choose the best Star Trek time travel storyline!

Choose from below or is the answer "Other" and a different episode like All Good Things” (TNG) or “Little Green Men” (DS9)?

— Daily Star Trek News (@DailyTrekNews) November 12, 2023

There was some fantastic interaction with 355 votes as well as over 34 comments.

So, as you can see the winner of the vote was “Yesterday’s Enterprise” but what followed was loads of great suggestions like these:

Cause and effect! So well done to shoot from different angles, perspectives. Jonathan Frakes killed it

— treklover (@treklover1) November 12, 2023

Very had call ,l would put Timeless ,Tomorrow Tomorrow Tomorrow past Tense, times arrow .

— jonny wyatt ❤️🖖 (@lovetilly1701) November 12, 2023

"Those Old Scientists." #StarTrekLowerDecks pic.twitter.com/dhEnGfB4WF

— 🌊Chris 🖖 (@stevalley) November 12, 2023

One of the earliest and most iconic time travel episodes comes from the original series with "The City on the Edge of Forever." Captain Kirk and Spock find themselves in Depression-era New York, facing moral dilemmas and the tragic consequences of altering history. This episode, written by science fiction luminary Harlan Ellison, is often praised for its emotional depth and exploration of the consequences of time meddling.

Moving forward to The Next Generation, "Yesterday's Enterprise" presents a dark alternate reality where the Federation is at war with the Klingons. The Enterprise-C, believed lost in battle years earlier, suddenly appears through a temporal rift, altering the course of history. This episode showcases the franchise's ability to blend action with thoughtful exploration of moral ambiguity and the impact of choices on the timeline.

Deep Space Nine took a more light-hearted approach with "Trials and Tribble-ations," celebrating the 30th anniversary of Star Trek by sending the crew back to the original series' iconic episode "The Trouble with Tribbles." The seamless integration of Deep Space Nine characters into the classic footage demonstrates the series' commitment to honoring its roots while playfully embracing time travel.

"Year of Hell" is a two-part episode in Star Trek: Voyager where Captain Janeway and her crew face a powerful temporal enemy capable of altering reality. This story provides a visceral exploration of the consequences of tampering with time, showcasing the resilience and adaptability of Voyager's crew.

The prequel series Enterprise delved into time travel with "Storm Front," a two-part episode set in an alternate history where the Nazis occupy the United States. While the narrative received mixed reviews, it highlighted the risks associated with temporal manipulation and the potential for unintended consequences.

Star Trek's time travel stories often grapple with ethical dilemmas, the impact of choices, and the fragility of the timeline. These themes have contributed to the enduring popularity of these episodes, resonating with viewers who appreciate the intellectual challenges posed by temporal narratives.

Certain time travel stories in Star Trek have aged remarkably well, thanks to their timeless themes and strong character development. "The City on the Edge of Forever" and "Yesterday's Enterprise" remain fan favorites, celebrated for their emotional depth and narrative complexity.

Star Trek's exploration of time travel has been a defining element of the franchise, offering a rich tapestry of narratives that span decades and series. From the philosophical questions raised in the original series to the character-driven stories of The Next Generation and the playful homage in Deep Space Nine, these episodes continue to captivate audiences, standing the test of time in the ever-expanding Star Trek universe.